This portfolio is submitted in partial fulfillment of my Annual Progress Review at the end of my first year of PhD research at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland.
It’s a presentation of archival work, work in progress and experiments produced under lockdown conditions during the COVID-19 pandemic (May 2020).
My doctoral research seeks to answer the following question: How can a somatic practice draw on embodied forms such as Butoh dance to encourage a direct realisation of ecological selfhood?
My practical research uses dance, music and multimedia to communicate shifts in my basic sense of self achieved through immersion in embodied-imaginary states and conditions. This portfolio offers a range of expressions and articulations of this, from documentation of live performances for an audience to somatic scores and prompts for you to try yourself, as well as video experiments.
As you experience the work, please try to be mindful of your own being, your body, and the mystery of who is looking out through your eyes, operating your fingers, and listening. How is your breathing?
I’ll remind you from time to time to check in with yourself.
My supporting writing on the context of the project can be found below.
Click on my limbs to explore.
I’m Not Here: Embodied Methods for Ecological Selfhood[if gte mso 9]>
Normal
0
false
false
false
EN-GB
< BACK
CONTEXT
This portfolio is submitted in partial fulfilment of my Annual Progress Review at the end of first year of PhD research at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland.
It’s a presentation of work in progress and experiments, produced under lockdown conditions during the COVID-19 pandemic (May 2020).
My doctoral research seeks to answer the following question: How can a somatic practice draw on embodied forms such as Butoh dance to encourage a direct realisation of ecological selfhood?
My practical research uses dance, music and multimedia to communicate shifts in my basic sense of self achieved through immersion in embodied-imaginary states and conditions. This portfolio offers some examples of this, ranging from documentation of live performances for an audience to somatic scores and prompts for you to try yourself, as well as video experiments.
As you experience the work, please try to be mindful of your own being, your body, and the mystery of who is looking out through your eyes, operating your fingers, and listening. How is your breathing?
I’ll remind you from time to time to check in with yourself.
My supporting writing on the context of the project can be found below
Click on my limbs to explore.
Let them become dark pools that expand to take up the space of your cheeks and forehead.
EndFragment
(Please read them several times to check)
Become aware of new eyes opening on the nape of your neck.
EndFragmentEndFragment
Please settle back into yourself…. Sink your awareness deep inside your body.
Some people do not hear a voice.
EndFragment EndFragment
NOW eyes open inside your chest cavity: loking inside, illuminating your internal organs.
See through these eyes.
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Feel that you are inside your eyes.
EndFragment
If you do hear a voice, is it yours?
These eyes see the space behind your body, like sonar.
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Become aware of your breathing.
Can you keep all these eyes at once?
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Who is it that looks out through them?
EndFragment
Where is it located?
Is it in your head?
EndFragment
Please close your eyes and listen.(
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Now two more eyes open on the soles of your feet.
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
< RETURN
Do you hear an internal voice when you read these words?EndFragment
The dark pools of your normal eyes.
The sonar at the nape of your neck.
The earth eyes on the soles of your feet.
The internal eyes in your chest.
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
(Where is your head?)
EndFragment
(Does it feel nestled within the bones of your skull?)
EndFragmentEndFragment
These eyes see straight through the floor, and down into the centre of Earth.
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Soften your eyes.
(How is your breathing?)
EndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragmentEndFragment
Let’s try an experiment.
EndFragment
(Do not worry if this is you).
EndFragment EndFragment
For some people a voice may seem to hover in the space in front of the forehead, where the eyes meet the world.
It may even seem to sit nowhere in space. EndFragment
EndFragment EndFragment
TEXT SPOKEN BY MICHAEL DURING THE PERFORMANCE
SECTION 1
A painful swelling of the face and throat
A yellow of the skin or the eyes
Headaches, drowsiness, hair loss, chills and sweating
Strange visions
Plastic of the heart and the hands
A reduced sense of touch
Keep this leaflet
Over 4000 different drugs running every day down drains and plugholes
Through sewers and cisterns
Out into the ocean
Where they whisper to the fishes and shrimp
Keep this leaflet
The following side effects have been observed:
An unusual production of breast milk in men and women
Dissociation and feelings of unreality
Isolation from family and friends
Plastic of the gums and brain
Memory loss
Difficulty sleeping
Difficulty waking up
An obscure feeling of loss or panic
But this medication has been developed with you in mind
It will soothe your yearning
It will dull your love
It will make things copeable
Imagine the jaws of a seagull closing on a shrimp
The moon is leaving us at a rate of 1cm every year
Plastic of the guts and feet
A reduced sense of touch
Nightmares, boredom, ennui
A reduced sense of touch
Ghosts along the spine
A reduced sense of touch
These pills may make you feel worse before you feel better
These pills may make you worse before you feel
SECTION 2
Please
Soft
Please
Soft
Please soften your eyes:
I’m searching for the moon in my blood
We’ve been moonless and tideless
And trembling and tideless
We’re missing each other.
We’re walking right through each other.
Focus on the hurt place
In the chest.
Lunary
I have a question:
Will you be the moon in my blood?
Soften your eyes.
Please soften your eyes.
Will you be the moon in my blood?
This is a live performance for three artists: Paul Michael Henry (choreography, dance, music, concept); Jer Reid (music, dramaturgy) and Jamie Wardrop (visual design and live video art). It was conceived in collaboration with marine biologist Dr. Alex Ford (University of Portsmouth).
The text below indicates what the audience experience on entering the performance space, as well as reproducing the programme notes they are given which explain the context of the piece.
Full video of a performance in Frankfurt in February 2020 can be seen further down (full screen option available). Below the video I have also included the live text spoken during the performance as it may not be clear on the recording.
AUDIENCE ENTRANCE
On entering the space one by one, the audience members are presented with a small installation on a plinth containing shrimp from the experiment on which this piece is based, placed in vials, next to vials of antidepressants cut into a half-moon shape. They are supplied with magnifying glasses to examine the specimens before taking their seat.
AUDIENCE PROGRAMME TEXT
This performance began with an experiment in marine biology. Professor Alex Ford of the University of Portsmouth measured the effects of antidepressants in coastal sea water on the behaviour of Shrimp.
Shrimp have evolved to stay in the shadows, where it’s safe. As the levels of antidepressants in the ocean rise, the shrimp show a tendency to swim upwards into the light, where they are often eaten by seagulls.
This effect is measurable because of the many millions of humans who take these medications. You might think of the experiment as a measure of secret human sadness.
Even today mental illness is personalised - an individual problem with no bearing on society and whether the structures of late capitalism are working or producing happy humans. Not to speak of other species. Not to speak of the Earth.
We are given pills and asked to go back to work. This economy is designed to grow perpetually.
If these things make sense, why are so many millions burying their despair beneath the ocean waves?
Even the shrimp have noticed.
Landing Page
This film was shot at the Devil’s Pulpit near Carbeth, Scotland. The location is reached by descent from a forest glade down a series of stone steps and a steep path, supported by ropes strung between the trees. Climbing down feels like a transition to an underworld, or perhaps to one’s own hidden psyche physicalised in the river and the rock outcrops carpeted with moss. The water is dark, brown, and fast flowing. I decided to use costume and makeup to formalise and encourage the shift from daily consciousness to something other.
The use of the ‘crab’ position is something I also do in Laughter at Being Crushed. For me it is a shortcut to an alternative plane of reality. My vision is inverted and my limbs must work backwards, foregrounding the difficulties of travelling. Features of the surroundings engage and penetrate the attention with a fresh urgency, and I feel myself become porous and open-vulnerable.
Watching the video now, I see myself as still half human but overtly embedded in the matrix around me with the clouds below and a rivery sky. Ghostly depths announce themselves, intimated by the processed birdsong on the soundtrack. This inversion of self also recurs in HYPERSEA and seems to me one very effective surrealist method of collaging either directly by reorienting the body, or in post production, in order to overflow the daily sense of self. Butoh dance is filled with such inverted images, such as feeling eyes on the back of the neck, as in WHO ARE YOU?
Home Page
I have tried with this portfolio site to achieve an isomorphism between form and theme: rather than the ubiquitous grid layout of rectangular frames found on most websites, I designed something that wanders and interlinks, opening outwards and returning. This comes at the expense of some clarity in navigation but even this I feel is appropriate as for me the exploration of ecological selfhood is meandering, unmooring and diffuse. It operates in spirals and outbursts rather than linear progression.
The twin themes on the the homepage are unity and dispersal, and I made use of three generalised myths to express this. The tree in the background forms an axis mundi, linking earth and sky and giving expression to the liminality of human existence, as well as constancy and a unity of experience. We live suspended between earth and sky, watched over by the stars.
Secondly, I read years ago of an ancient Babylonian myth concerning Tiamat, a sea goddess and symbol of primordial chaos whose body was dismembered; the heavens and earth were created from her separated limbs. This accords with my own experiences of my being as a microcosm reflecting the macrocosm of the cosmos (a notion incorporated in many faiths and in the magickal aphorism As Above, So Below). The dismemberment of my body parts on the homepage is intended as an articulation of this myth as recapitulated by every being.
Thirdly, one version of the Greek mythic story of the princess Ariadne has it that she feel in love with Theseus, giving him a ball of thread with which to find his way out of the labyrinth which he entered in order to kill the minotaur. I have extended this notion to show a ball of thread at the centre of the screen representing my atomised, isolated selfhood. Ariadne guides me out of this conceptual labyrinth, but ecologically and in many directions. The self she leads me towards is plural, diffuse and interconnected.
Who are you?
These pages are obviously prompts for the reader / listener, intended as a guide towards a shifting sense of self. They are a reimagining of exercises from Butoh (the eyes appearing all over the body, which sensitises the skin and encourages somatic and kinaesthetic perception), and from Nagatomo’s re-reading of phenomenology (the audio exercises guiding towards an experience of the subject-body which is felt to emanate beyond the borders of the skin). I included audio both with and without supporting sound design, allowing the listener the option of drifting on a sound bed, or simply listening to the instructions without distraction to focus on their own bodily perceptions.
SHRIMP DANCE
This 50 minute performance gestated for around seven years before finally being premiered in Glasgow in 2019. I am dissatisfied with its presentation here due to the video being essentially static documentation from the back of a theatre; as such much of the atmosphere is missing, and moments when I enter into the audience are out of shot. This being said, I include it because SHRIMP DANCE is something of a summation of my performance practice up until 2020.
The work of the performance from one angle is to take the tiny shrimp with which Dr. Ford conducted his experiment (he sent them to me through the post), and over the course of 50 minutes make them important. The theme of microcosm-macrocosm is again present, as is the attempt to critique neoliberal ‘self-responsibilised’ selfhood by making links between the communal conditions of human society and the mental health of individuals within it. For me, the miracle of Dr. Ford’s experiment is that it gives verifiable rebuttal to Cartesian dualism (sort of): how humans feel inside is changing the behaviour of sea life hundreds of miles away. This phenomenon is deep enough that I found the need to throw all the artistic tools at my disposal at it: dance at the core of the performance, but also music, text and video art. If the piece survives as part of my final PhD portfolio I aim to stage a performance specifically for video with multiple camera angles, or perhaps arrange a performance for assessment.
LAUGHTER AT BEING CRUSHED
As explained within the performance notes on this page, Laughter is to some extent a trauma piece. I used the spiritual conceit that suffering and trauma are brutal openings of the small self, exposing its vulnerability and unsurvivability so thoroughly that in the end one is forced to break open and accept a new self, maskless, incapable of hiding behind a persona. I hoped that if I could make myself so naked, I would be able to meet others in the audience in a particularly honest and truthful way.
CORONA BODIES
These writings emerged during the last few months of lockdown in Glasgow. I live alone in a tenement flat, and have experienced a cascade of emotional states involving isolation and disconnection, but underneath this new opportunities to connect. I’ve heard trees answering me when I speak to them, and the electrical hum of other humans passing me even though we keep our distance from each other. I’ve found for myself that this must be intentional and ritualised, sometimes in the form of internal mantras as in Heart Walking. It is a slow undoing of the atomised self achieved in unlikely conditions: though more isolated than ever, I am trying to find evidence, instead, of interdependence and coexistence.
COMMENTARY
Chopka
Heart Walking
Viral Apostrophe
The 2 Metre Body
The 2 metre Body
Begin indoors
In my case that’s a third floor tenement flat
Living room of 1.9 x 4.6 metres (2.9 metres high)
This means my corona body always overflows my flat
On at least 2 sides and sometimes 3
I am invading my neighbours
If I stand against the wall of the living room
I can spare one of them
But there’s nothing I can do about the one below
Short of sleeping on the ceiling
Think of a mirror self below the floor
Feet on the ceiling and head extending into the furniture
Perhaps I sometimes have my teeth in his breakfast
This radial self
My virus body
Delimits one way in which I am dangerous
Or vulnerable
A wet mist that precedes my skin
Visualise it maybe as a haze
A trembling of the air
I leave traces for several days
Depending on surface material
Go outside now
(Leave a slug’s trail on the stairs and across the close)
Use gloves for the communal door
The pavements didn’t envision this outcome
Remember radiality
Don’t fixate on your front body
There are also the sides and behind and above
You are blending
Be alive to ghosts
Everyone on the street shimmers outside themselves
Do not encourage paranoia
Find a graceful way to interpenetrate these strange bodies
Shy smiles or eyes straight ahead
The ones with masks and gloves, the ones who seem unperturbed
Play with it
The corona body is just one of your entries into this world
Hidden till illuminated by the dark light of pandemic
Viral Apostrophe
I ask Corona how it’s doing
I ask what it needs
How is to be so round
And small and everywhere
Do you feel like a squatter? Or misunderstood
An honest attempt at flourishing
Ostracised and hunted
Colour blind coloniser
Invisible Liebensraum
Equal opportunity friend maker
But why the old and immuno-compromised?
Have you heard about the Vitamin D thing?
(Are you sure you’re not a little bit racist?)
Corona how is it to be famous
How long did you plan this
Do you get lonely too?
Heart Walking
Begin indoors
Sit comfortably with the spine straight
Sink into your heart
The actual organ within your chest cavity
Electromagnetic blood being
Image the other hearts around you
Neighbours through the walls
Insects below the floorboards
Tune into these with your heart radio
An invisible nerve extending from your heart to every other heart
Now go walking
Your attention is biased towards your heart
Walk as though led by it
(You might find yourself turning left more than normal)
On encountering another being
Silently say to them
“Because we depend on each other, I’m keeping my distance”
If you’re feeling brave go one further:
“Because I love you, I’m keeping my distance
To protect you”
Say these things with the lips of your heart
Results are swift
Chopka
Find a tree
Throw your arms around it like a lover
As you breathe out feel that your are offering your lover carbon dioxide
As you breathe in feel that your lover is offering you oxygen
Keep going for several minutes
Caress the tree and feel its skin
Talk to it out loud
Don’t actually fuck it without consent
LAUGHTER AT BEING CRUSHED
This solo performance began when I wrote to author Coleman Barks in 2014 to ask permission for use of his translations of the poetry of Persian Sufi Rumi. He replied warmly to the effect that I was welcome to use his work in ‘whatever a Butoh performance is’…
The particular poem in question is the address of a single chickpea to the chef who is boiling it. The chickpea pleads why are you doing this to me?
The key line for me is in the chef’s reply: You think I’m torturing you; I’m giving you flavour.
The annihilation of a small self through the traumas and trials of life can be perceived, with grace, as an opening. Crushed to a pulp, there is no choice but to be open to what is beyond the self, to mingle and merge with it. Whether this is bad news depends on perspective and the self who is adopting it.
The performance structure is conceived as a series of trials, woundings and defeats, escapings from the skin until finally what is underneath is liberated (some sort of regained innocence and ability to have wide eyes of a child). I read of Rumi that he was so lost in the ecstasy of the Beloved he would sometimes bow down at the feet of dogs and children, seeing them as they truly were. The only thing more ridiculous I could think of was to do it now, in the 21st century, after all that we’ve seen. The last movement of the performance sees me circulating in the audience, bowing down to each being in turn and gazing in their eyes. If it goes well this is beautiful and people cry, but it wouldn’t work without the trials beforehand. I believe (and have been told) that I’ve managed to escape pomposity with this gesture. The hardest instance was when my mother was in the audience and I bowed down to her.
I’ve toured this piece in Scotland, England and the United States. The excerpts below are from a performance in Chicago in 2017.
Please close your eyes and listen.
2. Where do you stop? (with music)
1. Eyes and Tongue
(5 minutes)
3. Where do you stop? (without music)
(5 minutes 30 seconds)
(7 minutes)